SPONSORED
This issue is sponsored by beehiiv
Your paycheck doesn’t have to be your only income stream.
Brilliance Brief pays me in three ways.
Brands pay to sponsor it. Other newsletters pay me to recommend them. And it’s where I promote my own services.
In three years, this simple newsletter has made me more than $93,000.
I run it on beehiiv because those three ways are built in: their Ad Network, Paid Recommendations, and digital products.
You have years of lessons and stories that other people need. Share them once a week, and your newsletter can become your next income stream.
It’s year-end review season.
Over the next few weeks, a lot of leaders will sit down with each person on their team and talk about how their year went.
Some of those conversations will be easy. Some won’t.
In the hard ones, a lot of leaders will hold back. They’ll soften the message. Or they’ll keep a little distance so it feels less personal.
Early in my career, I was taught to keep that distance.
It was one of the old rules of management: Don’t be friends with your people. Keep work and personal life separate.
After 26 years of leading teams, I’ve come to the opposite view.
One of my earliest mentors is the reason.
The toughest boss I ever had
His expectations were very high. Nothing slipped through the cracks with him.
He was crystal clear about what needed to get done. Then he gave me the freedom to figure out how.
I could take ownership. Try things. Make mistakes and learn from them.
And he was always there when I needed someone to bounce ideas off.
We worked together for years. Over time, we got to know each other’s families and spent time together outside of work.
He still held me to the same high standard.
And I worked harder for him than for almost anyone.
When he pushed me, I knew it was because he believed I could get there.
What 19 words did for a group of 7th graders
Psychologist David Yeager and his team found the same thing in a middle school classroom.
Students in 7th grade wrote an essay about a personal hero. Their teachers marked up each essay with critical feedback. Then students got the chance to revise it.
Each essay came back with a short note from the teacher.
Half the students got this note:
“I’m giving you these comments so that you’ll have feedback on your paper.”
The other half got this one:
“I’m giving you these comments because I have very high expectations and I know that you can reach them.”
Same teachers, same comments. Only the note was different.
The biggest change showed up in the students who had the most reason to doubt their teachers were on their side.
Among the Black students in the study, 71% revised their essay after getting the second note. With the first note, only 17% did.
The second note answered the question everyone asks when they get criticized: Is this person on my side?
My mentor answered that question every day. He had very high expectations of me. And I never doubted he believed I could meet them.
How to use it in your reviews
1. Say the standard out loud.
Tell them what great looks like in their role next year. Be specific.
2. Say why you’re telling them.
Before the hard part, tell them you expect a lot from them because you know they can do it. Use your own words, but say both parts.
3. Say how you’ll help.
Name one thing you’ll do to support them. A weekly check-in. A roadblock you’ll clear. An introduction to someone who can help.
Then step back and let them figure out the path.
Try this today
Pick the one review you’re most nervous about.
Write down the hardest thing you need to tell that person.
Above it, write one sentence that tells them why. You expect a lot from them because you know they can get there.
Read it out loud once before you walk in.
The toughest boss I ever had made me better because I always knew he was on my side.
Your team will give you their best when they know the same thing about you.
Until next time, stay brilliant.
Justin
P.S. Who pushed you to be better, a tough boss or a tough teacher? Hit reply and tell me. I read every one.

